I wouldn't see her again.
Everyone suggesting talking to her, the whole reason to pay a premium is so you can skip the nonsense.
That's the reason for
you. I'm not trying to stick my dick into an unwilling hole, that is the opposite of what I want. Just because you paid doesn't guarantee that she enjoys everything you do. Being indifferent to what's going on with them isn't something I can do.
The math doesn't even make sense either. If I'm having great sex with someone, multiple times a week for weeks and I have one weird incident, it makes no sense to throw all that away bc of one bad session. You're taking a bigger chance with some rando than the person you KNOW you've had long-lasting chemistry with.
However you position it, not trying to resolve or move past it is, well... it's a decision alright.